Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Rihanna - Redemption song (live Cover)
Collapse
X
-
-
Originally posted by LarsVerb View PostI hope u not serious man.
Made by a man that put all his passion and struggles in the song, redone by someone that dont have any feelings by it and think she lives the thug life.
No thanks please.
Comment
-
Originally posted by LAWestCoastRida View PostShe Did The BEST She Could with Covering Such a Legendary Song, Of Course She Can't Have the same emotions because She Hasn't gone through what She Has & that's not Her fault, She Did Very Well In My Opinion.
But there are songs you cant touch, and seriously dont need to touch. Touching these songs is the same as killing someone. And this song is one of them.
Comment
-
I don't see how you can kill a sing or how it can be compared to killing a person by performing a cover of it, no matter how good or bad it is. "Redemption Song" by Bob Marley is indeed one of the greatest, most passionate songs ever sung and I doubt that anyone will ever be able to touch what he did with that song, but I personally enjoyed this cover. I don't understand how you can say that there's no passion in it, while it clearly is, or she is a better actor than we all believed (watch "Battleship", she isn't). Even if the cover was bad or you do think so, it couldn't be made equal to destroying it.
A song like "Redemption Song" is like a diamond, it's timeless, indestructable and as long as it isn't lost somewhere, it will hold its worth. If you don't like the performance, go ahead and turn it off, listen to the original and keep enjoying it. There's no reason to hate on another person's point of view, which is exactly what a cover is; a point of view.Last edited by Tsubotai; 05-04-2012, 07:55 PM.
Comment
-
rihanna kinda fails here but i dont blame her for that
she is an amazing artist, the song just didnt fit her style and her voice
still nice to see her spreading bobs message,
see top comment on youtube, this guy is right ...
Comment
Who has read this thread:
Comment